Monday, January 20, 2014

Should Christians Keep the Torah?

I was asked in an email about this issue and here is my response. I thought that some of you might like to read it.
***

Hi M,
I would be happy to answer your question. When I am teaching about this topic I point out to people that there are two things to keep in mind when reading the New Testament. 

First, it would have never occurred to the early Jewish followers of Yeshua (Jesus) that God would expect Jews to stop obeying the Torah. Why would the God of Israel expect Israel to stop its faithfulness to the Sinai covenant? It does not make sense. In fact, we see quite the opposite. There was an expectation, or maybe assumption, that gentiles coming to faith in Yeshua would also convert to Judaism, because this was their paradigm. The radical and momentous decision made in Acts 15 is that God was doing something new with the gentiles and therefore they should not require gentiles to take on Torah observance. 

I am convinced that this was the reason for the giving of tongues. The Jewish followers needed a clear and outward sign from God that the gentiles were saved without first becoming Jews. This is why you see the repeated reaction of surprise (Acts 10:45; 11:18)

Paul, therefore, seems to argue against the Torah but what he is really arguing against is expecting gentile Yeshua-followers to take on these practices. He argues that if this is required then you are saying that the cross did not have efficacy to save; clearly in his view a great distortion of the Besorah (Good News).

Second, the traditions and rules of the Pharisees was a novelty in Yeshua's day. They had not been around for very long. They were very popular with the people, however, especially in Judea. What the Pharisees did was brought the ritual practices of the Temple to ordinary everyday Jews. Their argument was that all Jews were priests since Israel was a kingdom of priests and therefore all of life needed to be treated as holy, not just the priestly activities in the Temple. Their ideas were not held by all and there was much controversy about these practices. Consequently there is a mix of practices by first century Jews and hence among first century Jewish followers of Yeshua. Notice that Yeshua is asked why some of his followers do not wash their hands before they eat. This implies that some did, and it also implies that Yeshua did!  

Paul, therefore, seems to be arguing against Torah laws when in fact he is dealing with these issues of ritual purity in the context of a community made up of Jews from varying types of backgrounds and practices and gentiles. When he talks about clean and unclean food he is not debating whether Jewish believers should eat pork not, but whether people of these various backgrounds can come together in communal fellowship when some a very stringent in their table purity practices and others are not.

It is my contention, along with most in our movement, that Christians are not expected to take up Torah observance; in fact to require it would be against God's will. But neither are Jews free from this covenant. Christians are certainly free to take up some of the practices as long as they see that they are doing this out of freedom and desire to relate to their Jewish brethren and not out of obligation.

I hope that this brief explanation helps. If the book you are reading is by David Rudolph it is a good resource. I have not the read the book but have studied under him and he is very knowledgeable. Another book that I would highly recommend is "Post-Missionary Messianic Judaism" by Mark Kinzer. He lays these issues out in much more detail than I have done here.

Please let me know if I can be of further assistance.

Shalom,
isaac

Sunday, January 12, 2014

How to Discern Bad Messianic Teaching

A friend recently asked me what I thought about a “Messianic” leader who is a very public figure. I had never heard of him but a quick search convinced me pretty quickly that he was probably a nut job. My wife called me on the carpet about being too uncharitable, and she is right. (She is going to make a great rebbetzin whether she thinks so or not!). But the reality is that there are numerous “Messianic” teachers out there who get a lot of attention from the church and they seem legit, when they really are not. These teachers prey on sincere Christians who don’t know any better. So I promised my friend that I would try to put together a list of items that are red flags for me when I encounter such folk. Hopefully this will be helpful to anyone who reads this.

 

Not all Messianic Jews would consider these to be red flags, so I am expressing views based on what I consider to be a mature Messianic viewpoint.

 

1. Teach that Christians should keep kosher, Jewish holidays, worship on Saturdays, etc…

Messianic Judaism holds that Jews who are followers of Jesus are still under the Mosaic covenant and are obligated to Torah observance. Christians are not. This was the decision in Acts 15 that Gentiles did not have to become Jews to join with Israel. Christians are certainly free to take on Jewish practices as a way of wishing to express solidarity with Israel, but they are in no way obligated to live as Jews. In fact, we applaud Christians developing their own traditions and practices that express their love of God in their own ways. Worshipping on Sundays, having Christmas trees, etc… are totally fine. Occasionally we get visitors to our synagogue who express this viewpoint and I tell them that they are thinking that they are being Jewish by holding such a position, but in fact they are the opposite. Judaism is an orthopraxic faith, and the traditions are valid if accepted and practiced by the community. Jews continue saying “mazel tov”, congrats, despite the fact that it comes from astrology (it means literally “lucky stars”). It has become an accepted phrase. Christians in like manner, should feel free to enjoy Christmas trees despite their pagan origins.

Some people of this persuasion will even tell Christians that they ARE Jews. This is categorically wrong and anti-biblical.

 

2. Dress like they live in Biblical times or just got off the boat from Eastern Europe.

There are a few, very few, Hasidic Messianic Jews. The vast majority of MJs come from Conservative, Reform, or entirely secular homes. Usually when people dress like this they are Gentiles who have become enamored with Jewish things and have no real concept of what it means to live as a Jew. (I was at a conference years ago where a guy dressed like a Hasid was eating a cheeseburger at McDonald’s!) It is because of this reality that some MJ leaders in our movement specifically do not sport beards in order to make the point. If you see someone dressed in these ways, you should be instantly suspicious.

A corollary to this is people who use Hebrew names like Nechamah or Yeshayahu. Unless they are from Israel, this should be a warning, especially if coupled with the above mentioned dress choices. Some sincere and level-headed MJs take on Hebrew names or Hebrew versions of their names. But all too often this is not the case. It is more due to a desire to sound “authentically Jewish”. This is one of the reasons that I prefer to go by “izi” instead of “Isaac”. (I am keeping my beard but am willing to modify my name!)

 

3. Excessively focused on End Times

Jews by and large are not focused on End Times. This is a signature Christian preoccupation. If a Messianic teacher is going on and on about End Times, they are either coming from their own Christian background or are catering to Christian interests. This is an immediate red flag for me.

 

4. Militantly Missionary

If a Messianic teacher is very focused on missions work, especially to Jews, this is a red flag to me. Messianic Judaism is not Jews for Jesus. The latter is a missionary organization that is focused on coverting Jews. Messianic Judaism is a congregational movement seeking to establish a home for Jewish followers of Jesus. These missionary groups are very appealing especially to evangelical Christians because of the focus on getting Jews “saved”. Much damage has been done by these groups because of their approach. MJ seeks to be an example of how to live both faithfully to Torah and to Yeshua (Jesus). Our message is that Jews can and should remain Jews as followers of Jesus. These missionary groups have little regard for the Mosaic covenant; many even teach that it is wrong. They are operating out of what we would call a “Hebrew Christian” mindset, rather than a Messianic Jewish one.

 

There may be some other ones, and I could go into more detail into each of these…

 

 

Monday, December 10, 2007

The Nine Chanukahs of Light

Today is Shabbat Chanukah. We are in the midst of a whole week of commemorating the events of the Maccabbean rebellion. We all know the story, that Mattisyahu and his sons led a war against the Syrian king, Antiochus, who had demanded that the Jews give up their faith and merge with the pagan Hellenism of the day. They were successful and recaptured the Temple. It had been desecrated with idols and the sacrifices of pigs. The Jewish soldiers cleansed the Temple, brought in the priests, and rededicated it. This is in fact where we get the name Chanukah, it means “dedication”.

There is a midrash, that says there was not just one Chanukah but actually seven.

The seven mentioned in the midrash are:

  • The Chanukah of Creation
    • In Genesis it says “when the heavens and earth were completed” The midrash says that “completed” refers to dedication because when Israel had completed all of the accouterments of the Tabernacle that Moses blessed them in dedication to be used in holy service. So, goes the midrash, God dedicated creation.
  • The Chanukah of the Tabernacle
    • As we just mentioned Moses dedicated the Temple to the service of Hashem.
  • The Chanukah of the First Temple
    • King David wrote a psalm for the dedication of the First Temple, which was actually performed by his son Solomon. Psalm 30 starts out, “mizmor shir chanukat habayit”, A psalm, a song, for the dedication of the temple.
  • The Chanukah of the Second Temple
    • In the time of Ezra when they rebuilt the temple, they dedicated it with sacrifices.
  • The Chanukah of the Wall of Jerusalem
    • When Nehemiah led the people to finish the wall around Jerusalem they dedicated it. In Nehemiah 12 it says, “And at the dedication of the wall of Jerusalem, they sought all the Levites from all their places, to bring them to Jerusalem to rejoice in the dedication”
  • The Chanukah of Maccabees
    • This is the Chanukah that we are currently celebrating.
  • The Chanukah of Olam Ha-Ba
    • In Isaiah 30 it says, “The light of the moon shall be as the light of the sun, and the light of the sun shall be sevenfold, as the light of seven days”. This, say our Sages, refers to the end of time, Olam Ha-Ba. When Hashem will dedicate the New Heavens and New Earth.

What I would like to propose to you is that there are in fact 9 Chanukahs, not 7; these round out the Chanukah menorah. In fact, that is my title for this sermon, “The Nine Chanukahs of Light.” The 8th Chanukah of light is the Chanukah of Yeshua. As we will see in a moment, He is our example of total dedication to Hashem. The 9th Chanukah of light is the Chanukah of us. Each and every one of us is called to dedicate ourselves Hashem. I would like to look at 3 specific aspects of Chanukah that Yeshua exemplifies and we are also called to.

First, Chanukah is about dedication to Torah.

Antiochus had ordered our people to give up Torah and adopt Hellenistic ways. Mattisyahu and his sons and those who fought with them refused to do this. They showed their dedication to Torah by resisting this forced enculturation and, with God’s help, defeating their enemies.

The book of Maccabees records Mattisyahu’s words to his sons as he lay on his death bed. He said:

My children, be zealous for the Law, and give your lives in behalf of the testament of our fathers. Be mindful of the deeds of our fathers, which they performed in their generations, that you may receive great glory and eternal renown. Was not Abraham found faithful in time of trial, and it was accounted to him for righteousness?... Be strong and courageous in behalf of the Law… gather about you all who observe the Law, and avenge fully the wrong done to your people.”

If it were not for their dedication to Torah, we might not even be here today. Judaism could have simply ceased to exist.

Yeshua Himself was also dedicated to Torah. Yeshua did not abrogate or cancel the Torah; instead He upheld it and gave it its fullest meaning. He said, “I did not come to abolish the Torah, but to fulfill it.”

His issue with the leaders of His day wasn’t that they obeyed the Law, but that they let ritual aspects of Torah supersede what He called the weightier aspects, namely mercy and compassion. He says to them, “You give a tenth of your spices—mint, dill and cummin. But you have neglected the more important matters of the Torah—justice, mercy and faithfulness. You should have practiced the latter, without neglecting the former.” Notice that He doesn’t tell them to not obey these lighter commandments, but that they should be practiced in addition to the weightier ones.

Yeshua showed His dedication to the Torah through His actions as well as His teachings. He consistently sent people that He healed to the priests for verification that they were in fact healed. He could have been a total rebel and told them not to mess with the priests and their rules. But instead He upholds their authority and ensures that they fulfill all of the aspects of Torah.

Chanukah calls upon us to also be dedicated to Torah. We are in an age not unlike that of the Maccabees. If you read historical accounts of Chanukah, you realize that observance was already on its way out when the edict came. Jews were already slowly being Hellenized; many had already fully assimilated into Greek culture. This is why the Sadducees were opposed to the doctrine of angels and life after death. They were priests highly assimilated into Greek culture. They felt it unsophisticated and contrary to modern philosophical thinking to believe in such things.

The reality is that it might have been for the best that Antiochus forced the issue with his edict, because it pushed the issue to the forefront. Had he not, some historians think that Judaism would have just simply slowly faded away.

Today is similar to that. We have a high rate of assimilation and inter-marriage. Torah observance is at an all time low in the United States and Israel. We must be dedicated enough to the observance of Torah that we do our part to preserve it. Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch said, “One single spark, loyally treasured in but one single Jewish heart, is sufficient for God to set aflame once more the whole spirit of Judaism.” Each and every one of us is that one small vial of oil, which God can do a miracle with.

Every morning we pray in the Shacharit service:

“Blessed are You, O Lord our God, King of the Universe, Who has sanctified us with His commandments and has commanded us to engross ourselves in the words of Torah. Please, Hashem, our God, sweeten the words of your Torah in our mouth and in the mouth of Your people, the family of Israel.”

The root word of Chanukah is Chanach, Chet-Nun-Chaf, which means “to train”. We are to train ourselves in Torah. Train like athletes do for a major competition.

The rabbis say that Chanukah marks a shift from Torah being transmitted by the prophets and the priests, to each individual Jew. When the Jews of that day were confronted with either apostasy or death, they were forced to internalize the Torah themselves and no longer just follow what their leaders said. After the Maccabean rebellion, the Torah is always quoted in the name of individuals. In the Mishnah we see references to the Torah of Rav so-and-so. We are called to make the Torah our Torah. We need to learn the Torah of Larry, and Julie, and Abby.

Chanukah calls us to be dedicated to God’s Torah, to teach it to our children, teach it to one another, and thereby preserve it.

Chanukah is also about being dedicated to shedding the light of Torah to the world.

We do this mostly by living out the precepts of Torah, in particular by doing gemilut hassidim, deeds of lovingkindness.

As the 8th candle, Yeshua is our example par excellence in this area. We see Him consistently being drawn to and reaching out to the down and out, the unappreciated, the rejected, and the ignored. He eats with tax collectors and prostitutes. He touches lepers and pays attention to cripples and the blind. These are people whom society in this day as well as in His day tends to just overlook and cast aside. Yeshua loves them, lives with them, and grants them dignity.

As the 9th candle, we too are called to live a life of chesed, of lovingkindness. The schools of Hillel and Shammai had a disagreement, as they often did, on how Hannukah menorahs should be lit. Shammai said that you should light all of the candles the first night and light one less each night. But Hillel said that you should light one candle the first night and one more each successive night because in matters of holiness we should be growing, not diminishing in them. This is the practice that our tradition has adopted. Chanukah is a call on us to be dedicated to growing ever more in our acts of hesed. In our own way, we can comfort the afflicted, give sight to the blind, heal the sick, and raise up those who are bowed down.

I have been reading lately Rabbi Jonathan Sacks’ book titled “To Heal a Fractured World.” This is an excellent book that I highly recommend. His basic premise is that what the Torah has given the world is this sense of being accountable for our fellow human beings. He says, there is divine justice, but God calls for human justice. He calls for us to act to stop injustices and to reach out to people who are in need. This is exemplified in God’s call upon Abraham to “walk before me and be perfect”. The rabbis interpret this to mean “Don’t wait for me to command you to do good. See the need and do it.” The Torah calls us to be people of lovingkindness.

As one Jewish mystic put it, “Another person’s physical needs are my spiritual obligation.”

We had an example this past week of one who lived this principle of taking care of others. Some of us were at the funeral of Allen and Larry’s father, Sam Singer. At the funeral we heard about how Sam was always there for people in his community, helping them out when they were in need. Allen talked about trying to fill his father’s shoes when his father had surgery some years ago. He was running about helping neighbors and widows with all kinds of things, wondering how his father did it all. This is a man who lived a life of chesed, a life dedicated to lovingkindness. Rabbi Dobrusin even connected it to Chanukah in his words at the funeral. He said, “Sam was a simple candle, but a candle that showed a light to all of those around him.” His life is an example to us all.

Yeshua said, “let your light shine before men, that they may see your good deeds and praise your Father in heaven.”

Maimonides said, “If a person is scrupulous in his conduct, gentle in his conversation, pleasant towards his fellow creatures, affable in manner when receiving them, not retorting even when affronted, but showing courtesy to all, even to those who treat him with disdain, conducting his commercial affairs with integrity… such a person has sanctified God’s name.”

Each and everyone one of us are a Chanukah of light. We can shed our light upon others around us through dedication to good deeds.

Finally, Chanukah is about being dedicated to the mission that God has given us in life.

The Jews in the days of the rebellion against Antiochus did not so much find God’s mission as it found them. The very circumstances that they were thrust into begged for them to stand up for Torah and the Jewish way of life and fight against tyranny.

Yeshua knew God’s mission for Him because it was revealed to Him by the Father. He dedicated Himself to fulfilling the office of Mashiach because it was God’s will for him.

Some of us will be like those in the days of the first Chanukah and discover what God wants us to do by the circumstances we find ourselves in. Some of will be like Yeshua had have God tell us what He wants. Whichever way we discover it, we need to seek out His mission for us and dedicate ourselves to its fulfillment.

We have been talking about mission. We are all called to the mission of observing and encouraging observance of the Torah. We are all called to do good deeds. Collectively, we as Jews are called to be a light to the nations, a holy priesthood. But each of us has are particular role, our sub-mission if you will in accomplishing this task.

Martin Buber said, “Every person born into this world represents something new, something that never existed before, something original and unique. Every person’s foremost task is the actualization of his unique, unprecedented and never recurring potentialities.”

Chanukah calls us to be dedicated to finding our particular mission in life and work towards its fulfillment.

Conclusion

In conclusion, I would just like to say that we should not be dismayed by the breadth and depth of these calls upon us. They indeed can be daunting. If you read a history of Chanukah, you will realize that the temple was dedicated before the war was over. Judah Maccabee sent soldiers to continue the fight with the city garrison while others began to clean up the temple. So we too can dedicate ourselves to these great tasks even though the battle isn’t over for us either.

Yeshua is the eighth Chanukah of light, our example of what it means to be dedicated to Torah, to the love of others, and to fulfilling our mission in life. He perfectly executed all of these.

As the ninth Chanukah of light, each of us are called to dedicate ourselves to Torah, to loving others and good deeds, and to fulfilling our mission in life. This Chanukah season, may each of us reflect on these and strive to fulfill them.

Proverbs says that each person’s soul is a lamp of Hashem. May we become a light that truly sheds light on all of those around us and may we all merit seeing that final Chanukah in the world to come. Amen.

Sunday, November 4, 2007

Images of God & Self

Last week a friend was sharing with me about how God used her to bring together a woman who had cancer and a man who God has given the gift of healing. He prayed over her and two weeks later the doctors declared her cancer free. Baruch Hashem! (praise God).

She was sharing with me that she is just stunned that she was given the privilege of being a small part of this miracle. And that she was struggling with what God wanted her to do now.

This conversation reminded me a few things that I would like to share with you all.

Encounters with God like this always affect us. They assault our image of God and also our image of ourselves. Maybe we are doubtful that God can move in this way and then suddenly we are confronted with proof that He indeed, at least on occasion, does! Suddenly God becomes mystery again. We thought that we had Him figured out and then He throws us for a loop. Or maybe we think that we are not worthy to see or participate in such things.

"Who am I to be used in such a way?" we ask ourselves.

This kind of assault on our images of God and self can be very unsettling. A very common response to this is to try to gain control of it; we want to figure it out. God has jumped out of the box and we want to find a new and improved box to put Him into. The reason for this is it feels safe. If we understand God and how He acts and we know who we are, then we can feel like we have control of the situation.

To quote C.S. Lewis in the Chronicles of Narnia, "He is not a tame lion."

My encouragement for all of us who experience such things is to resist the temptation to try to control it and figure it out. Let God be mystery, for this is what He is. We miss out on many blessings and opportunities for spiritual growth when we do try to "figure it all out".

God calls us to be open and available to Him. Beginners on the spiritual path think that they are the initiators. This is a form of control and a way of holding back. As long as we control the encounters and set the agenda, we can steer away from anything that makes us feel uncomfortable or uneasy.

A few years ago I was teaching a class on spiritual disciplines. A person approached me and said that he would like to come to the class but he was too afraid of what God might say or ask of him. I gently encouraged him to try the class but he never came. Many of us live like this, holding God at arm's length, afraid to get too close.

If anyone continues on a serious spiritual quest for God, eventually he or she will be confronted by God demanding that He be in control of the relationship. It is at this point that we realize that He is the initiator and we are the responders. This is a more mature way of walking with God (and also more freeing and joyful!)

When you have these miraculous encounters with God, resolve yourself to being open and just take in the experience. Don't try to analyze it, diagnose it, pack it in a box and wrap it up tight. Just let it be.

Also, use the experience to explore what God may be wanting to show you about Himself or yourself. Ask him these two questions:

"God, how do you want me to see You in light of this event? How should my image of you change?"

"God, how do you see me? Do I have distorted images of who I am that you want to expose and heal?"

Monday, October 15, 2007

Letting scripture read you

Both Christian and Jewish mystics throughout the centuries have urged us to not read scripture, but to let it read us. We can open ourselves up to hearing God's voice speaking to us as we meditatively read scripture. If we do this, we will find that the same passage will say different things to us at different times in our lives.

I experienced this recently. A few weeks ago I was listening to an interview with Robert Alter, who has produced a new translation of the book of Psalms. As he was discussing his translation of Psalm 23, I was taken back to a time many years ago where I had an incredible experience with reading it. It was during a prolonged period where God seemed so distant to me. It seemed like my prayers were just bouncing off of the ceiling. This had been going on for over a year when one night I sat down and read Psalm 23. As I read "Yea, though I walk through the valley of death, You are with me..." I suddenly had this tremendous insight that God was with me this whole time, even though He was "invisible" and that I needed to know that He was present and to trust Him. This brought me great solace.

As I was listening to Robert Alter read his version of Psalm 23, however, I had a very different experience. I realized that rather than God making Himself "invisible" to me, it was the other way around. Lately, I have been holding God at arm's length, not wanting to be too close to Him. I have been avoiding God. In essence, I was the one making Him "walk through a dark valley" through my inattention to His presence. Unlike years ago, where I was fervently seeking Him and He was no where to be found, now God was fervently seeking me and could not "find" me.

So this same passage, read at two different times, years apart, said something different to me. The first one brought me solace and comfort at a time when I really needed it. The second time brought me a challenge and a wake up call to see that I was ignoring God.

I encourage all of you to let scripture read you rather than simply reading scripture. If you do so, in time, you will hear the voice of God speaking to you where you are at right now in the present moment.

Thursday, October 11, 2007

A Rare Privilege

Last week was the ending of Sukkot (Feast of Tabernacles). I had ordered a book that contains all sorts of stories and anecdotes about the holiday but did not get it until afterwards. There was one story that I liked enough to send along even if the holiday is over. Here it is.


A Rare Privilege

Rabbi Mordechai was not very wealthy but each year he managed to save up enough money to buy a nice lulav and etrog set[1]. On his way to a nearby city to buy it though, he came across a man who was crying next to a cart and his dead horse.

Filled with compassion, he asked the man, “Why are you crying?”

“My horse was just killed in an accident and without him I am unable to earn a living” the man said.

Immediately Rabbi Mordechai gave his lulav & etrog money to the man so that he could buy a new horse. He said, “God commanded me to wave the lulav and etrog, but He also commanded me to take care of the needy.” So he returned home empty handed.

When the village folk asked to see his new set, he told them, “All Jews will say a blessing over the lulav and etrog during Sukkot. But this year, only I have the rare privilege of saying it over a horse.”



[1]The lulav is a bundle of 3 plants; myrtle, palm, and willow. An etrog is a citrus fruit grown in Israel. These are waved in praise to God throughout the 7-day feast as commanded by God in the Torah.

Monday, October 8, 2007

We are all messed up

I was talking with a friend recently about a situation which revolves around a person who is a Christian and loves God but who is so completely caught up in their own issues that they are making life very difficult for themselves and those around them. This person is completely blind to the fact that much of their thoughts and behavior are driven by past hurts and present fears.

We tend to think that just because people are believers that they "have it all together". The reality is quite the opposite. We are a collection of fairly messed and sometimes downright dysfunctional people who happen to love God and seek to follow Him. We are in need of much healing. Like it or not we are more often than not driven by our past hurts, current desires, and fear of the future.

Quite often the message that we receive in our congregations is that since we have committed our hearts and lives to God, we don't need anything more; that we have somehow arrived. I think that such messages do all of us a great disservice. As followers of Yeshua, as people who desire to be holy and whole, we should be constantly striving to improve ourselves and freeing ourselves from these driving forces within us that lead to hurting ourselves and others. We need to be seeking God's face on a regular basis asking for Him to reveal to us where we need healing.

Quite often we are totally blind to the reality of this. We cannot see without careful self-awareness and introspection.

Where are you driven by past hurts? Do you react strongly to certain "triggers"? Are you harboring past resentments? Are you afraid of the future? Do you have inordinate desires for something?

These questions are difficult to face, but they must be on a regular basis if we are to grow into God's image. These things keep us from being unconditional love. We need to ruthlessly ferret them out of our lives through prayer, through reflection, and through talking with trusted friends or a spiritual leader.


peace,
izzy